Back to blog
Insights

Hotel Managers Know Their Employees Matter. So Why Do Employees So Often Come Last?

By Yuanbo LiNovember 14, 202617 min read

When guests keep complaining about long waits at check-in, the front desk team is often asked to work faster and smile more. But a queue can tell us as much about staffing, room readiness and the way departments work together as it does about the person behind the desk. In my years in hotel operations, I’ve come to ask a question whenever service falls short: have we given our people what they need to deliver the experience we promise our guests?

Hotel Managers Know Their Employees Matter. So Why Do Employees So Often Come Last?

There is a saying in the hotel industry that we are all too familiar with: Employees are our most valuable asset.

You will find this sentiment in almost every hotel's corporate culture statements, staff meetings and management training programmes. We talk about putting people first, encourage managers to care for their teams, and frequently remind ourselves that happy employees create happy guests.

Yet there is a question worth asking: If we all recognise how important our employees are, why do their needs so often come last in day‑to‑day hotel operations?

When a hotel struggles financially, management's first instinct may be to increase sales, cut costs or raise room rates. When guest satisfaction declines, we introduce more training, conduct more inspections and tighten performance assessments. When employees begin leaving one after another, only then do we start asking whether our salaries are competitive enough or whether something has gone wrong with employee engagement.

None of these management responses is necessarily wrong. But when we look at them together, an interesting contradiction emerges:

We expect our employees to deliver exceptional guest experiences, yet we do not always place the same importance on the experiences our employees have at work.

This is neither a new problem nor one unique to hospitality. Many years ago, while reading Ron Kaufman's work on service management and exploring related service philosophies, I began reflecting on the relationship between employee experience, guest experience and business performance.

As I gained more experience in hotel operations and guest experience management, this question became increasingly relevant to my everyday work.

Drawing on the established Service‑Profit Chain framework, along with observations from hotel operations, I would like to share my perspective.

Hotels Pursue Profit. But Where Does Profit Really Come From?

Every commercial hotel needs to make a profit.

Without sufficient financial returns, it becomes difficult to maintain facilities, invest in people and sustain operations. For hotel owners and management teams, paying close attention to revenue, operating profit, costs and return on investment is entirely reasonable.

But if a hotel wants to achieve sustainable profitability over the long term, what exactly should it focus on?

Perhaps we should start with profit and work backwards.

To generate more profit, a hotel generally needs to create more valuable business, improve the profitability of its existing business, or both.

Sustainable business growth depends, in part, on a stable customer base and repeat business.

To encourage guests to return, competitive pricing and attractive products are important. But so is their confidence that the hotel will consistently deliver on its service promises.

That confidence is often built through one positive stay after another.

And where do those positive guest experiences come from?

Facilities, product design, service processes and brand positioning all play their part. But ultimately, there is one factor that cannot be overlooked: people.

Even the best service philosophy needs employees to put it into practice. Even the most comprehensive service standards need employees to deliver them. Even the most advanced operational systems still rely on employees to make judgements and solve problems on the ground.

So what enables employees to deliver high‑quality service consistently?

Strict inspections? Continuous training? Higher performance expectations?

All these things matter, but they may not be enough.

Employees also need reasonable workloads, adequate resources, clearly defined responsibilities, appropriate empowerment, and a working environment in which they feel respected and recognised.

If these conditions are consistently absent, simply demanding a better service mindset is unlikely to achieve the desired results.

This line of thinking closely reflects the Service‑Profit Chain, a framework introduced by James L. Heskett and his colleagues in 1994.

The Service‑Profit Chain connects internal service quality, employee satisfaction and loyalty, employee productivity, external service value, customer satisfaction and loyalty, and ultimately business profitability and growth.

One distinction is important here: the framework does not suggest that satisfied employees automatically make a hotel profitable.

The relationship between employee satisfaction and profitability is not that straightforward. Market demand, operating costs, brand competitiveness, product quality and revenue management also influence the final outcome.

What the framework does reveal, however, is a fundamental management principle:

Profit is a business outcome. The organisational capability to generate profit is what managers need to build and sustain.

If we focus exclusively on the final result while overlooking the processes that produce it, we risk creating a familiar situation: cost‑cutting improves this month's financial report, only for employee turnover and declining service capability to create new costs further down the line.

We Keep Adding to the Guest Experience While Quietly Taking Away from the Employee Experience

Hotel managers are no strangers to the idea of adding value to the guest experience.

Consider an example.

A guest has stayed at a particular hotel 19 times and is about to make his 20th visit.

The hotel recognises the milestone in advance and prepares his favourite hot drink, a personalised welcome gift and a warm greeting from several employees who know him.

The gift itself may not be expensive, but the experience could become a memorable part of his stay.

Why?

Because the hotel has made him feel remembered.

Now consider another situation.

A high‑tier loyalty member regularly stays at properties belonging to an international hotel group. Over time, he has developed clear expectations of the benefits and recognition associated with his membership.

But on this particular day, the front desk is exceptionally busy. Employees are struggling to cope with arriving guests. There is no proper greeting, membership benefits are overlooked, and essential information is not passed between departments.

The guest's established expectations have not been met.

In the first example, personalised service creates a positive surprise. In the second, the hotel fails to deliver even what it has already promised.

It would be easy to conclude that employees simply need to be more attentive, more proactive and more focused on the guest experience.

But I would ask a different question:

Was the problem at the second hotel really just a lack of service awareness among its employees?

What if the front desk team had already been working under excessive pressure for hours?

What if staffing levels were inadequate?

What if the hotel's systems and interdepartmental processes were inefficient?

Under such circumstances, even employees with excellent service attitudes may struggle to deliver consistently.

These are not problems that another training session can necessarily solve.

More importantly, while we are constantly finding ways to add value to the guest experience, are we inadvertently taking value away from the employee experience?

Think about a hotel that once held regular employee recognition ceremonies, presented certificates and bonuses, and publicly celebrated outstanding contributions.

Over time, those practices become less frequent, less meaningful or disappear altogether.

Staff meals become less varied. Employee benefits are gradually reduced. Staffing levels become tighter, while performance expectations continue to rise.

Work that once required three people may now be expected of two.

And when employees raise concerns, the responses they hear are variations of:

"Everyone is under pressure."

"Business is difficult at the moment."

"We all need to take ownership."

How are employees likely to feel if this continues month after month?

Of course, controlling costs during difficult trading periods is part of a manager's responsibility. No business can increase staffing or employee benefits without limits.

But there should be a carefully considered boundary between responsible cost management and undermining the employee experience.

Some savings appear immediately in financial reports. Their potential consequences — increased turnover, higher recruitment and training costs, service failures and lost guests — may not become visible until months later, and may not even appear in the same report.

When the benefits of cost reduction are immediately visible but the damage to service capability takes months to emerge, managers may naturally pay more attention to the former and underestimate the latter.

This, I believe, is one of the management contradictions the hotel industry needs to examine more carefully.

The Same Employee, Two Hotels, Two Completely Different Attitudes

American author and speaker Simon Sinek once shared a real experience from the Four Seasons Hotel in Las Vegas.

During one of his visits, he met an employee named Noah at the hotel's coffee bar.

Noah was warm, engaging and genuinely enthusiastic. He greeted guests with a smile and seemed to enjoy every interaction.

Simon could sense that Noah's friendliness was not simply the result of someone telling him to smile. He genuinely enjoyed what he was doing.

Curious, Simon asked Noah whether he liked his job.

Without hesitation, Noah said he loved it.

Simon then wanted to know why.

Noah explained that managers at the hotel regularly checked in with him, asking how he was doing, whether he needed anything, and what they could do to help him perform his job better.

It was not just his direct manager. Other managers behaved in much the same way.

Noah also described his experience at another hotel where he had previously worked.

There, managers appeared far more concerned with identifying mistakes and correcting employees. His priority had been to avoid attracting management's attention, get through the working day and collect his wages.

The same Noah displayed two completely different attitudes in two different working environments.

For me, the most revealing part of this story is not simply how friendly the Four Seasons managers were. It is how they understood their role as managers.

One type of manager tends to ask:

"Why didn't you do this properly?"

Another might first ask:

"What support do you need to do this properly?"

The two questions are not mutually exclusive. Good managers must also hold people accountable.

But if management becomes little more than identifying mistakes, pointing them out and penalising poor performance, employees may begin to see avoiding criticism as their primary objective.

Under those circumstances, how can we reasonably expect them to remain proactive, enthusiastic and eager to create memorable guest experiences?

Hotels need standards. They need inspections. They need performance management.

But inspections should not exist merely to identify who has made a mistake. Training should not simply involve repeatedly telling employees what the correct procedure is. And performance management should not become an exercise in assigning blame.

The true value of a manager lies not only in determining whether employees have done their jobs well, but also in helping them develop and maintain the ability to do their jobs well.

Perhaps the Real Problem Is Not That Hotels Do Not Care About Employees, but That Their Management Systems Do Not Reflect It

I do not believe that hotel managers generally lack concern for their employees.

In fact, many managers understand the importance of their teams and genuinely want to support them.

But there is a difference between a manager personally valuing employees and an organisation consistently reflecting that value through its management practices.

A hotel may repeatedly emphasise employee care during staff meetings and require department heads to conduct regular employee conversations.

Yet if day‑to‑day management assessments remain overwhelmingly focused on costs, revenue, complaint numbers and inspection results, employee experience may gradually become something that is important but never particularly urgent.

Consider a department head who successfully reduces labour costs by cutting staffing levels.

From a short‑term financial perspective, the department appears to be performing well.

At the same time, however, employees face heavier workloads. Some experienced team members begin looking elsewhere. Those who remain must take on additional responsibilities, and service quality gradually becomes less consistent.

If senior management sees only the reduction in costs without examining employee turnover, overtime, service productivity and guest feedback, it may mistakenly regard the decision as a management success.

Now consider another department head who proposes investing in training, improving operational tools or adjusting staffing arrangements.

These measures may strengthen the hotel's long‑term service capability, but they may also face resistance because they increase short‑term expenditure.

This creates a contradiction.

Management recognises the importance of employees in principle, but its operating systems do not necessarily reinforce that belief.

This does not mean employee experience should take precedence over commercial performance in every situation.

Nor does it mean that higher employee satisfaction is always better, or that better employee experience simply means providing more benefits.

A hotel with relaxed expectations and weak performance management may have employees who feel comfortable at work, but that does not guarantee high‑quality service.

What is needed is balance.

Hotels must establish clear service standards, responsibilities and performance expectations while ensuring that employees have the skills, resources and support required to meet them.

They must consider short‑term commercial performance alongside the workforce stability, capabilities and organisational efficiency that support long‑term results.

That is where employee experience management should make a meaningful contribution.

Employees Who Never Receive a Guest Compliment Deserve Recognition Too

When we think of outstanding hotel employees, front office, restaurant and guest relations teams often come to mind.

These employees work directly with guests. Their smiles, communication skills and ability to resolve problems are highly visible.

When a front desk employee successfully resolves a complaint, the guest may even write a personal letter of appreciation.

But what about an engineering employee who identifies a potential equipment failure and fixes it before any guest is affected?

Or a room attendant who notices a maintenance issue during cleaning, reports it immediately and prevents a possible complaint?

They may never receive a compliment.

Because, from the guest's perspective, nothing went wrong.

Yet from a hotel management perspective, preventing a problem can create just as much value as successfully resolving one that has already occurred.

Hotels are full of employees whose contributions are not always visible.

Engineers, room attendants, purchasing officers, finance teams and other support functions may have limited direct contact with guests, but together they sustain the entire service operation.

When they perform their jobs well, their work is often taken for granted. When something goes wrong, however, their performance can suddenly attract considerable attention.

This is why employee recognition should not rely exclusively on guest compliments, online reviews mentioning specific employees, or touching service stories that are easy to share.

A mature recognition system must also identify the less visible contributions that consistently create value for the hotel.

Recognising these contributions is not merely about showing respect.

It also sends an important message throughout the organisation about which behaviours and achievements deserve to be encouraged.

Do Not Let Guest Satisfaction Become a Numbers Game

Beyond employee experience, there is another issue in hotel management that deserves attention: how we understand guest satisfaction.

Today, almost every hotel places considerable importance on online reviews and guest satisfaction indicators.

OTA ratings, positive review percentages, complaint rates and recommendation scores have become part of everyday operational management.

This is a positive development.

Such data can help hotels understand guest perceptions, identify service shortcomings and assess whether improvement initiatives are working.

The problem arises when prolonged pressure to achieve certain scores gradually shifts management's attention from improving experiences to protecting numbers.

When a negative review appears, the first concern may not be why the problem occurred, but how much the review will affect the hotel's overall rating.

When a guest complains, the immediate priority may become persuading the guest to remove the review rather than resolving the underlying issue.

Some hotels may even attempt to create the appearance of positive guest sentiment through fabricated reviews.

This fundamentally confuses the measurement of performance with the purpose of managing performance.

Imagine a hotel receiving repeated complaints about long check‑in waiting times over three consecutive months.

Management might instruct front desk employees to work faster, smile more or offer welcome drinks to guests while they wait.

Such measures may help to some extent.

But if the root causes are poor staffing arrangements, delayed room readiness or ineffective interdepartmental communication, these actions are unlikely to solve the problem.

Look a little deeper.

If front desk employees have been working under consistently excessive pressure, and department heads lack the staffing or systems necessary to support their teams, the issue becomes connected to employee experience.

A guest complaint does not always reflect an employee's service performance alone. It may also reveal weaknesses in the organisation's internal management.

The purpose of guest satisfaction management, therefore, should not simply be to achieve a higher score.

It should help managers identify what genuinely needs to improve.

Scores can legitimately serve as operational targets and form part of performance management. But they must not replace the fundamental purpose of improving the guest experience.

Managers need to ask more than:

"Why has our rating dropped?"

They should also ask:

"What is this complaint really telling us?"

"Is the problem related to employees, processes, resources or management practices?"

"Have our corrective actions actually improved the guest's experience?"

If every complaint results in nothing more than another training session, another departmental meeting or another completed corrective action form, the same problem may occur again with the next guest.

A management process may have been completed on paper without the underlying problem ever being resolved.

Effective Service Management Should Connect Employee Experience with Guest Experience

The Service‑Profit Chain provides a useful framework for understanding hotel operations.

But the real value of a management theory lies in how it informs everyday decisions.

From my perspective, there are at least three things hotel managers should pay closer attention to.

First, do not simply ask whether employees have met the standard. Ask whether the hotel has given them the conditions necessary to meet it.

When an employee fails to deliver the expected standard, managers should distinguish between a capability issue, an attitude issue and a problem with resources or processes.

Different problems require different solutions.

A capability gap calls for training and coaching. A resource problem requires adjustments to staffing, tools or processes. A failure of accountability may require clearer expectations, supervision and appropriate consequences.

Not every service problem is caused by a lack of service awareness.

Second, do not only reward excellent service recovery. Reward effective problem prevention.

Successfully resolving a guest complaint deserves recognition.

But employees who identify potential problems early and prevent guests from experiencing dissatisfaction deserve recognition too.

Better service quality comes not only from responding quickly when something goes wrong, but also from identifying and addressing risks before they affect guests.

Third, stop treating employee satisfaction and guest satisfaction as unrelated management subjects.

If a department experiences rising guest complaints, increasing employee turnover and growing overtime over several consecutive months, management should investigate whether these trends are connected.

Likewise, if a hotel improves working conditions, redesigns processes or adjusts management practices, and subsequently sees positive changes in both employee engagement and guest feedback, it should examine which interventions contributed to those outcomes.

This does not mean that simultaneous movements in different indicators automatically establish cause and effect.

Rather, it means managers should analyse operational problems from a more complete business perspective.

Mature service quality management should not focus solely on individual performance indicators.

It should also seek to understand the conditions and processes that produce those results.

If We Expect Employees to Care for Guests, How Are We Caring for Employees?

Why do you get up early, work late and spend hours preparing guest rooms?

Why do you continue repairing a leaking pipe even when your clothes are soaked through?

Why do you stand outside the hotel entrance for hours in freezing cold or scorching heat?

Why do you remain at work during public holidays while others are spending time with their families?

We could say it is simply part of the job. A professional responsibility. A way to earn a living.

And none of those answers would be wrong.

But I have always believed that the value of working in hospitality should extend beyond completing assigned tasks.

Ultimately, what we do is intended to help people feel safe, comfortable, respected and cared for while they are away from home.

It is about creating experiences that go beyond the basic provision of accommodation.

Yet that sense of care should not exist only between employees and guests.

When we ask employees to treat guests with genuine warmth, we should also reflect on whether managers treat employees with the same sincerity.

When we expect employees to anticipate guests' needs, we should ask whether managers make a genuine effort to understand the difficulties their teams face.

When we encourage employees to create memorable moments, we should consider whether the organisation gives them sufficient trust, support and recognition.

This does not mean employees should be exempt from accountability. Nor does it mean hotels should sacrifice operating efficiency in pursuit of employee satisfaction.

Quite the opposite.

Effective management requires a sustainable balance between commercial results, service standards and employee experience.

A hotel can invest heavily in upgrading its facilities. It can hire talented designers to transform its spaces. It can launch marketing campaigns to attract more guests.

But even the finest physical product cannot entirely replace the human interactions that define much of the hospitality experience.

And the quality of those interactions is often influenced by how the organisation treats its employees long before a guest walks through the door.

Perhaps the hardest competitive advantage for another hotel to replicate is not teaching employees how to deliver great service, but creating an organisation in which employees are both capable of and willing to deliver it consistently.

So, the next time a hotel finds itself struggling with declining service enthusiasm, falling guest satisfaction or service standards that never seem to take hold, perhaps its managers should do more than ask employees to change.

Perhaps they should ask themselves:

What kind of experience do we expect our employees to create for our guests? And what kind of experience are we creating for our employees?

Author's Note: This article draws on my personal observations and experience in hotel management, alongside the Service‑Profit Chain and related service management principles. The Service‑Profit Chain was developed and articulated by James L. Heskett and his colleagues and is not my original concept. The story of Noah is based on a hotel service experience publicly shared by Simon Sinek. Certain hotel scenarios presented in this article are illustrative examples rather than documented incidents at specific properties. This article was originally written on 6 January 2019 and first published on Zhihu. It has since been revisited, revised and expanded.

#Hotel Operations#Employee Experience#Guest Experience#Service Quality#Service-Profit Chain#Employee Recognition
Stay in the loop

Get inspection insights in your inbox

Join our list for new guides and product updates. No spam — unsubscribe anytime.